Dismissal, Unfair & Constructive Dismissal

Dismissal from employment can be a challenging and complex issue, especially when it involves allegations of unfairness or coercion. Understanding the nuances of unfair dismissal and constructive dismissal is crucial for both employers and employees in South Africa. This comprehensive guide covers the essential aspects of these types of dismissals, including their meanings, legal grounds, procedures, and potential outcomes.

Types of Dismissals in South Africa

• Summary Dismissal: Immediate termination without notice, usually due to gross misconduct.
• Fair Dismissal: Dismissal following proper procedure and with a valid reason.
• Unfair Dismissal: Dismissal without a fair reason or proper procedure.
• Constructive Dismissal: Resignation due to intolerable working conditions.

Unfair Dismissal

What is Unfair Dismissal?

Unfair dismissal occurs when an employee's contract is terminated by the employer without a fair reason or without following a fair procedure. According to the Labour Relations Act (LRA) in South Africa, every employee has the right not to be unfairly dismissed.

Grounds for Unfair Dismissal

Unfair dismissal can occur under several circumstances:

• Lack of Fair Reason: The employer fails to provide a valid reason for the dismissal.
• Procedural Irregularities: The employer does not follow the proper dismissal procedure as outlined in the LRA.
• Discrimination: The dismissal is based on discrimination due to race, gender, age, disability, or other protected characteristics.

Constructive Dismissal

Constructive dismissal happens when an employee resigns due to the employer creating a hostile or intolerable work environment. This type of dismissal is also protected under the LRA.

Constructive dismissal is recognized when:

• The working conditions are so unbearable that the employee feels forced to resign.
• The resignation is a direct result of the employer’s conduct.
• The employer has made continued employment intolerable.

Legal Framework and Procedures

CCMA and Unfair Dismissal

The Commission for Conciliation, Mediation, and Arbitration (CCMA) handles cases of unfair dismissal. Employees can lodge a complaint with the CCMA within 30 days of the dismissal. The CCMA will then facilitate conciliation and, if necessary, arbitration to resolve the dispute.

Dismissal Procedure South Africa

A fair dismissal procedure includes:

Notice of Allegations: The employee must be informed of the allegations against them.

Opportunity to Respond: The employee must be given a chance to respond to the allegations.

Disciplinary Hearing: A formal hearing should be conducted where the employee can present their case.

Decision and Communication: The decision should be communicated to the employee in writing, with reasons for the dismissal.

Outcomes and Compensation

Unfair Dismissal Payout

Employees who are unfairly dismissed may be entitled to:

Reinstatement: Returning to their previous job position.

Compensation: Financial compensation, usually up to 12 months’ salary for unfair dismissal or up to 24 months’ salary for automatically unfair dismissal.

Other Remedies: Depending on the case, other remedies may include changes to employment terms or conditions.

Dismissal Payment in South Africa

Upon dismissal, employees are entitled to:

Notice Pay: Payment for the notice period if not worked.

Severance Pay: If retrenched, at least one week’s remuneration for each completed year of service.

Outstanding Leave Pay: Payment for any accrued but unused leave days.

Other Benefits: Any other benefits stipulated in the employment contract or company policy.

Key Considerations

Grounds for Immediate Dismissal South Africa

Immediate dismissal, or summary dismissal, is justified in cases of serious misconduct, such as theft, fraud, or gross insubordination. However, the employer must still follow a fair procedure.

Van Deventer and Van Deventer Inc. – Labour Law Attorneys

Navigating the complexities of unfair and constructive dismissal requires a thorough understanding of South African labour law. Employers must ensure compliance with legal procedures to avoid disputes, while employees should be aware of their rights and the avenues available for recourse. For professional legal assistance, our Labour Law Attorneys offer expert guidance on all aspects of dismissal and labour disputes.

For further information or legal support, contact Van Deventer and Van Deventer Incorporated. Our experienced team is ready to assist you with all your employment law needs.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Bond & Transfer Calculator